You can't give advice to be a "player", this girl is saying she "loves" these guys and advice to date both isn't the right thing to do! Plus the girl's question is "who should I choose" so that is the question to answer. I would say "D" b/c it sounds like he would be the right guy and ready for a relationship! But then again if she loves "T" she can't ditch him while he's down.

Panelist Wanna Be