Love&Learn
Ask a Question
Reader Agatha
yellbut.gif
yellbut.gif
dblubut.gif

Back to what triggered this response.

 
Am I wrong to exchange my engagement ring?
Panelist Jody said:

Boy are you materialistic!

Reader Agatha Responds:

I disagree because no one should be required to wear some "married uniform" as if it's mandatory. It's not.

He Got the Ring He Wanted

If she had given her husband a ring he doesn't like, should he be expected to wear it? I think there's a sick double standard going on here. In fact, she said her huband got EXACTLY the ring he wanted!

Men Don't Have To Wear Wedding Rings

Even though people in American society consider themselves "modern", a married American woman is expected to wear a ring to tell others that she is no longer available. Not many married American MEN wear wedding rings because there's still some stigma of jewelry being considered a feminine accessory. No one seems to demand that men proclaim their marital status in a visual way.

Now let's say that a wife wishes to wear her ring because she likes jewelry. If there's a significant investment in a piece of jewelry meant for everyday wear, then shouldn't it be worn instead of kept in the darkness of a jewelry box, and shouldn't it be an expression of the individual's taste instead of an arbitrary design decision made without her consultation? Why do you accuse her of being materialistic? She has to look at that ring EVERY DAY!

Rude To Force a Gift

I think Jody is confusing the intent of a gift with the sentiment of a marital symbol. Of course, it seems rude to reject someone's gift. But isn't it also rude to expect someone to wear something they don't like?

Superstition

And what in the world is the importance of "blessing" jewelry and other inanimate objects? Will some horrible curse rot her finger if she exchanges her ring? That sounds more superstitious than religious to me.

Can you really expect someone to force themselves to stop caring about something in order to not hurt someone else's feelings?

Wear the jewelry you like, for goodness sake!

Agatha

 

 
Click here to see the full question & the Panelists' responses.

 

What do you think of this Answer?

What part are you reacting to?

What do you think?

Signature to use with your reaction:

Your gender:

Male:
Female:

Your age:

Your location:

optional: email address (WILL NOT BE PUBLISHED)

 

 

 

 

Site Design by:
Bleeding Edge Design