HomeMainMeet the PanelAll QuestionsYour HostAsk the Panel

Question

Dear Panel,

There seems to be a thin line dividing what's acceptable in a friendship between members of the opposite sex. If one of my former girlfriends happened to have had sex with the guy she says is currently "just friends with," I have had a difficult time accepting their friendship. Some might call this jealousy, but is it really?

-- Just Wondering

[read the entire question below]

Dear Panel,

Platonic Relationships

What are the boundaries for men/women who have friendships with members of the opposite sex? Despite what Billy Crystal said in When Harry Met Sally, I full-heartedly believe that men and women can be friends and have completely platonic relationships -- I have several myself and have always been comfortable with my former girlfriends' platonic relationships with their guy friends. And keep in mind, by "friendship" I mean regular contact with the person, not merely seeing/talking with them a few times per year.

Friends Who Have Sex

However, for me, there seems to be a thin line dividing what's acceptable in a friendship between members of the opposite sex. If one of my former girlfriends happened to have had sex with the guy she says is currently "just friends with," I have had a difficult time accepting their friendship. Some might call this jealousy, but is it really? Or is there a universal stigma associated with a friendship that includes sexual activity in the past? Admittedly, I have thought about accepting invitations to be sexually active with some of my women friends, but because I would hate to jeopardize our friendship's future for a few romps in the hay, I have forgone the opportunities.

Crushes or Exes?

On the other hand, if the girlfriend had had deep feelings for this person, but for some reason or another, they never had sex or pursued a romantic relationship, then I'm pretty comfortable with their continued friendship. A few of my exes stated that they didn't understand why I felt this way, and claimed that, for them, it would actually be the other way around when it came to any past lovers with whom I might still be friends with.

The Double Standard Against Men

From almost everything I've read in some of the women's magazines like Cosmo and such, they're always telling their readers to not put up with their boyfriends still hanging around with their exes. But there always seems to be a double standard for women handing out with their exes. The magazines and the women that read them seem to believe that us guys should be comfortable with their friendships with exes. Now, this doesn't apply to every woman out there -- I've found many who feel the way I do --but for those that it does, what gives?

Should I Be Noble or a Player?

In addressing this 'double standard,' is my decision to not have sex with my woman "friends" a noble one, or should I expect a woman to completely accept these flings from the past and vice versa?

Does One's Past Affect a Present Friendship?

So, I guess the question I propose (and please pass around to all your friends, the more answers the merrier) is, "What past history between friends of the opposite sex is acceptable between two people trying to build a long-term, healthy relationship?"

-- Just Wondering

 

Love & Learn: Relationship advice from a panel of non-experts.

 

 

 

Site Design by:
Bleeding Edge Design