Love&Learn
Ask a QuestionMeet Judith

Main
Meet the Panel
All Questions

Judith Answers:

Dear Catch22,

You've Already Made the Decision

OK -- so your dilemma is that if you confront her you may end up hearing something you didn't want to hear; and if you don't you live a lie for a few months. Because you've already made a decision in this circumstance -- you know she is keeping secrets from you and whatever the truth is the secret-keeping can't be good.

Patra He shouldn't bother confronting her.

The straight answer is: confront her, get it over with, break up, and move on.

Maybe Your Suspicions Are Wrong

However, I think there is a larger lesson here. It is unfortunate that this particular woman does appear to be keeping secrets, because you could've learned something if your suspicions weren't confirmed: no one will ever be open and honest and comfortable with you if you already think they are a liar.

I and My Boyfriend's "Distrustfulness" Thing

I've had this problem myself. Before my current relationship grew up and became healthier, we had this crazy little "distrustfulness" thing going. My then-boyfriend suspected me of everything (just this general suspiciousness, not of a particular evil) and because I was afraid of making him more insecure or uncomfortable or whatever, I would keep TOTALLY HARMLESS truths from him like who I'd been talking to on the phone or who I studied for my test with, etc. Even though I had done nothing wrong.

My Unabashed Truths

Well, of course he caught me in these little untruths, and trusted me less. It turned into this vicious cycle. Finally, I couldn't take it anymore, and decided I would give him the unabashed truth and if he didn't like me for me, to hell with him.

How We Built Trust

In our case, it worked out well -- he trusted me more and I was more trustworthy. But he also had to get a grip on his insecurities and realize that in my life I was going to interact with men, have male friends, etc. and that I still loved him no matter what.

In Your Case, Just Give Up

In your case I doubt that will happen. You are new enough and not important enough to each other to make a real commitment to change both of your behavior. So, just give up and take it as a lesson learned.

-- Judith

 

 

What do you think of Judith's Answer?

What part of her answer are you reacting to?

What do you think?

Signature to use with your reaction:

Your gender:

Male:
Female:

Your age:

Your location:

optional: email address (WILL NOT BE PUBLISHED)

 

 

 

  ..

 

 

Site Design by:
Bleeding Edge Design