HomeMainMeet the PanelAll QuestionsYour HostAsk the Panel

How do I get her back if I can't support her?

Dear Panel,

...Dan pays for all her bills, including her daughter's pre-school. Financially, she couldn't move out even if she wasn't bound by this lease, and I don't make enough money to pay for a place for me, Amy, and her daughter...

– Worried in Wisconsin

[read the entire question below]

Dear Panel,

I am a sensitive, caring guy and am still deeply in love with my ex-girlfriend.

Amy is the most beautiful woman to ever grace the earth. She has a three year old daughter whom I love as my own.

Dan is Amy's present boyfriend. They now live together and he pays for all of Amy's bills.

She Replaced Me

Hope

This sounds like a pattern for her.

Amy and I were together for about two years, and I still love her with every ounce of my soul. We lived together for a little over a year. Six months ago, she broke up with me and a few weeks later, she replaced me with another man (Dan) and soon moved out with him.

She Came to Return My Things

I hadn't talked to her for the last four months until about a week ago when she showed up at my door to return some things of mine. That night we sat up for about 3 hours talking about life and just chit-chatting. We didn't mention our situation or say anything about any relationship at all. She asked me to help her buy a computer and I agreed to help her later that week.

The night we went shopping for the computer, we talked for about 5 hours, this time it was about us. I found out that she hasn't been very happy in her present relationship lately and that she misses me and still loves me. She wants to be with me but she cannot leave him because she signed a one-year lease to the apartment where they live.

Bound By Money

She also does not work but goes to school. Dan pays for all her bills, including her daughter's pre-school. Financially, she couldn't move out even if she wasn't bound by this lease, and I don't make enough money to pay for a place for me, Amy, and her daughter.

We Had a Great Time

All in all though, we got along like we used to and we both had a great time. We even talked about the love we used to make and about how great it was. We even fought off the urge to do it that night. It was almost as if we were back together again.

This is only the beginning. I apologize for such a long question, but it's very involved.

Dan's Violent Reaction

She and I were out together late last Friday, and were out very late Saturday with a couple friends of hers. Saturday night her daughter stayed at my place. That night, Amy came home to a furious Dan. She tried to sleep as he punched several holes in the walls and the bedroom door.

Survivor

She doesn't even want to use you – she went to another friend to spend the night.

Fed up, she finally grabbed a change of clothes and went to spend the night at a friends house.

His Attempted Suicide

The police were called by a neighbor of theirs because of the noise, and when they found him, Dan was passed out in the garage with the car running.

I found out about this before my ex did and I had to be the bearer of bad news. He was in the hospital and within an inch of his life. She immediately went to visit him in the hospital.

It's been a few days and I haven't heard from her since, even though she told me she'd call with updates on how he's doing. I found out from her mother that he's okay now and in some psychiatric clinic for the next 3 days.

In Limbo

I am so worried about her and her daughter. I can't even imagine how she's taking all of this. Why won't she call me or answer my calls? Does she think this whole thing is my fault? Does she just need time to recover? What is my next move in getting her back? What is her next move in life? Does she dump this crazy guy or stay with him in fear that he'll do it again? Will this guy try to hurt her or her daughter? I have no idea what to do or what to think. Amy and her daughter are the two most important people in my life. Please help me on this.

What can I do to help her?

Worried in Wisconsin

 

Mr. Survivor, Judith, Hope, and Charlie answer this question.

 

Love & Learn: Relationship advice from a panel of non-experts.

 

 

 

Site Design by:
Bleeding Edge Design