Love&Learn
Ask a QuestionMeet Judith

Main
Meet the Panel
All Questions

Judith Answers:

Dear Assessing Compatibility,

Marriage and Living Together Are Completely Different

I think living together is a decision independent of marriage. When it is right to live together, you will want to for many reasons: you want to spend more time with each other, you want to share the responsibilities of a household together, and you will want to make a "semi-permanent" commitment to each other.

"Semi" because it is easier to break up from a living together situation but permanent because a household still needs to be dissolved if a break up should occur, suggesting a high degree of commitment.

Living Together Isn't a Test

Jimmy

Wrong. He'll find out who she really is.

It isn't a test for marriage, it is different than marriage. Being ready for marriage is a whole different set of desires and commitments.

If you want a publicly recognized commitment, some "faith" that you will be together forever, and to start a family (not necessarily with children, marriage itself creates a family) then you are ready for marriage.

JudithYou're Not Ready

As you see, these decisions are quite different and living together isn't a test. Truthfully, from your letter, you don't sound ready for marriage and you might not be ready to live together.

As far as hands-on experience, while sex is great, I'd be surprised that a high number of marriages end because of sexual incompatibility.

In a marriage, it is impossible for both partners to ignore a problem like that - and therapy is widespread enough that there is help if there is a problem that significant.

She Has a Different Attitude About Sex

That doesn't mean that your attitudes about sex might be different enough to even prevent you from getting there.

Aaron

Good point. To start, he should ask her about her beliefs.

You have very different concepts of sex - she thinks virginity is something to be cherished and enjoyed; you think sex should be tried and tested. Does this tension between cherishing/adventure come up in other areas of your relationship?

You Can't Make Her Into Something She's Not

You obviously can't force her to do something she doesn't want, so I think you were writing more to justify your side of the arguments. Instead, I would suggest you look at what you want, with this person, and make your decisions together based on that.

Judith

 

 

What do you think of Judith's Answer?

What part of her answer are you reacting to?

What do you think?

Signature to use with your reaction:

Your gender:

Male:
Female:

Your age:

Your location:

optional: email address (WILL NOT BE PUBLISHED)

 

 

 

  ..

 

 

Site Design by:
Bleeding Edge Design